Tuesday March 22, 2011, from 12:15 to 1:15 and Monday, March 28, 2011, from 12-1:30 in the West Conference Room of the library.
Below you will find information that the QEP Planning and Topic Selection Steering Committee collected in preparation for the selection of the QEP topic. You might find it helpful in creating a proposal.
In January, the QEP Planning and Topic Selection Steering Committee conducted a survey to gauge attitudes about how the Wesleyan community might think about possible topics for a Quality Enhancement Plans. The results, sorted by entire survey and by groups, are attached.
From the November Board of Trustees meeting through the middle of February, the QEP Planning and Topic Selection Steering Committee conducted 25 focus groups of faculty, staff, students, alumni and trustees to generate discussion on what would be important to Texas Wesleyan University to enhance students learning. The transcripts are below. Phase One focus group questions are general in nature and, with the results of the Survey, led to the development of the questions for the Phase Two focus groups.
Please Click To Read Each
QEP Focus Group - Phase 1
Board of Trustees Group 1
Board of Trustees Focus Group
November 18, 2010
Jeff Smith, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
In public education, we tend to focus on standardized testing, and by the time students get to the university level, they do not know how to reason or problem solve. In an age of accountability, teachers at the primary and secondary levels are forced to stick to mastery of content and have little time to focus on higher critical thinking skills.
They need to be able to think for themselves and develop analytical and critical reasoning skills.
Students should be able to pose questions, look for answers and evaluate their findings.
Students need a value-centered education (specifically focusing on ethics in public life). Included in that should be a renewed understanding of a “work ethic.”
Students should know the process of “Plan – Act – Reflect.” They need to know how to apply what they learn to all aspects of their lives.
Also identified was a need to teach better communication skills. Students need to learn how to benefit from collaboration and partnerships in life.
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
The small class size is a huge plus for the university. The fact that the university is focused on a value-centered education is also a plus. The openness and transparency of the university is also a benefit.
Out of that, the students tend to come away with a passionate understanding (excitement) about their chosen career fields and educational endeavors.
Our appeal is a solid ethical approach to education and the development of students for their futures.
2. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Career-related opportunities would be important. Students often graduate without knowing what they really want to do because they don’t know what there is to do. It would be good to increase our internship opportunities in collaboration with our various partners so that students will have had an opportunity to gain advanced understanding about options in their chosen fields in an effort to increase employee longevity after a company has spent resources training the graduate for a specific position or career.
As was discussed in the presentation on Career Services, better collaboration and partnership between the university and a broad base of community business leaders (in both for-profit and not-for-profit spheres) would be critical to this success.
2. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
One respondent said, “I think of my wife, who is passionate about what she learned and how she is going to apply that to life.”
Graduates of Texas Wesleyan benefit from long-lasting relationships with faculty, staff and fellow students.
Our graduates are well-rounded in the sense that they have had a broad education and have had more opportunities to be involved in things that are not necessarily in their field. These people become more well-rounded members in their work and communities.
We have people who are givers and leaders in their communities.
Please click to close Board of Trustees Group 1
Board of Trustees Group 2
Focus group participants: Board of Trustees
Date: November 18, 2010
Focus group leader: Michelle Rigual
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
Communication
- Students should do a lot of writing so that they can learn the skills of writing. Need to combat the poor writing and spelling that come with the use of text and email.
- They need to learn to speak well (content) and comfortably (non verbal communication that conveys confidence and interest).
To be critical, lifelong learners
- The college experience should create an open, critical mind in students.
- Develop an analytical mind so can see beyond the superficial, understand, and challenge (experts, politicians, popular ideas, etc).
- Necessary to always be in learning mode and to keep learning throughout life, to keep up with society (technology, politics, etc) and stay engaged.
- They need to learn to do their homework in college so that they can do “homework” in life.
To be well-rounded (similar to previous but distinct)
- It is the time to explore and find your passions.
- In the end, you should have background and be well-rounded. Example of what you don’t want is a physician who knows nothing but medicine.
- To be well-rounded (and open to learning) because people often end up having approx 3 distinct careers in their professional life.
Others:
- Become independent.
- Integrity: don’t want to see people make $$ then destroy the company.
- Integrity: exploring the Idea of giving back.
- To be involved in campus life.
- To be realistic about marketability.
2. Is there anything unique about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
Church Relationship:
- Gives us different focus.
- The value system that is part of being a religious-related school = more emphasis on service and how students relate to the world.
- Incumbent upon us to focus on service to others.
Student Profile:
- Fewer “silver spoons”
- Less feeling of entitlement
- Students understand that they will have to “earn it”
- Most of our students will work throughout school which creates challenges but also the plus of experience and learning to be workers.
- More than our share of 1st in family to go to college.
Other
- Small size means that we know the students.
4. If you could choose one thing that would prepare our students—enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Communication
- Writing skills
- Oral communication - succinct, able to present self as an educated person, able to meet and deal (look in eye, talk to you, possessing interpersonal skills)
- Meaningful content of information – being well educated enough to understand what is asked, matching the depth of information provided in the answer to the question at hand as well as to the education level of the person hearing it.
Good attitude
- If you have a good attitude, can work on aptitude; doesn’t work the other way around.
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Did not get to this question due to lack of time.
Please click to close Board of Trustees Group 2
Education Doctoral Students
Education doctoral students
January 22, 2011
Edita Ruzgyte, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Sense of community
- Life long friends
- Skills to get future job in the competitive market
- Knowledge and skills to be leaders
- Alumni – communication and close relationship with them
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Individualized attention for each student
- High quality professors, who have practical experience in their own field
- “Warmth”
- Student /teacher ratio
- Professors are very available for the students
- Teachers are interested and invested in students’ success
- Students are encouraged to develop and practice critical thinking
- Students are not just numbers
- Departments listen and respond to student’s feedback
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- Internships
- Practical experience
- State board exam preparation
- Connection between university and community
- Broader spectrum of education
- Study abroad trips
- More advanced distance learning
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Resourceful, do not take legal education as given
- Alumni are very involved
- More public spirited – pro bono work
- Community connected
- Well rounded and matured, usually it is their second career
Please click to close Education Doctorate Students
Upper Level Music Students
Focus Group Questions
Studies in the Performance of Music Class
(Upper Level Music Students)
January 20, 2011
- What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Preparation for real world life
- Dealing with people
- Independence
- Encouragement and confidence
- Self motivation
- Responsibility
- Punctuality
- Time management
- Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Individual concern about student progress/well-being
- Sense of community
- Fosters independence by requiring responsibility
- More personal
- If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- More field experience
- Higher expectations
- Offer more information about getting into graduate school
- Offer the GRE on campus
- Make graduate school more appealing through more promotion of graduate studies (both here and other schools)
- More opportunities to investigate and explore job market in specified fields
- When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Success
- Dedication of alums
- Limited in scope (lack of breadth in some programs)
Please click to close Upper Level Music Students
University Senior Staff
Focus Group Questions
Senior Staff
January 10, 2011
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
Critical thinking
Synthesis/analysis
Discern between legitimate and illegitimate information
Communication: oral and written
Discipline specific skills
Learn to learn continuously
Work with others
Ethical framework
Personal discovery
Job transferable skills
Time managements/money management
Leadership skills
Confidence in abilities
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
Personal attention
Nurturing environment
Caring attitudes
Diverse student population
Hands-on learning
Opportunities
Internships
First-generation students
Leadership positions
Undergraduate research
Faculty mentors
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Non-classroom experiential learning
Take advantage of diverse community to learn teamwork
Required internships
Technology skills (esp. Microsoft office)
Service learning/volunteerism
Study abroad
Cross-disciplinary learning
Basic business classes
Deliberately planned co-curricular activities that support learning goals of curriculum (learning objectives for non-academic programs that support curriculum)
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Quality
Work ethic (ready to work hard)
Tenacious
Successful
Confident
Caring
Gracious/crateful
Competent
Please click to close Senior Staff
Signature Experience Leadership Team
Focus Group Questions
Signature Experience Leadership Team
January 17, 2011
What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Critical thinking
- How to learn
- How to handle responsibility
- Good decision making
- How to demonstrate skills
- Transferability
- Application of skills
- Well-roundedness
- Time management
- How to be successful at a job
- Effective negotiation of new experiences
- Work with diverse population
- Write well
- Conflict management
- Self-efficacy
- Confidence/motivation
- Independent thinking
Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
(I kind of changed this question and asked what the academic goals were for SELT)
- Prepare for graduate school or job
- Confidence in finding and using resources
- Student engagement
- Active learning
- Learner-centered learning
If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- Experiential learning
- Requires critical thinking
- Internships before senior year
- On and off campus
- Comprehensive information literacy across curriculum
- Technology learning overall
- Connecting classroom with communities of influence through Pre-professional literacy
- Professional literacy
- Can’t lose content learning
- Global literacy
When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Teachers and lawyers
- Nurse anesthetists
- No connection to Wesleyan (no contact with generations of alumni)
- Hard workers
- Card about degree
- Leading efforts at workplace
- Don’t end up in job they thought they would
- Shape-shifters
- In the community
Please click to close Signature Experience Leadership team
Wesleyan Alumni
Focus Group Questions
Alumni Executive Board
January 8, 2011
What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
How to think
Time Management
Leadership
To learn there is more to be learned
Global/world view/Cultural awareness
Thinking outside the box
Self-awareness/idea of who they are
Qualitative and Quantitative Reasoning (assess situations, think things through
Independence
Writing/communication
Well-rounded education
Learn from others
Working with others
Apply degree to getting a job/become functioning member of society
Career preparation
Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
Personal connections
Size is an asset/smaller is good
Attitude more important than size
Importance of teaching—relationships with faculty and staff, open-door policy
Atmosphere of the humanities **
Programs like 3PR
Liberal arts core/GEC
Crossover courses for a wide view of disciplines
Supportive campus
If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Communication skills—communicate what you learned
Get confidence
Guidance & counseling for degree and career
Bridging internships/mentorships from the beginning (help in determining major)
Ability to adapt/tools and skills to adapt to changing careers and transitions
Be prepared for change
Message that it’s okay to change after researching different fields
When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Well-educated
Professional grounded
Prepared
Life-long friendships: remain connected, sense of belonging
Confidence
Leadership
Self sufficient
Loyal
Independent/Entrepreneurial
Successful
Ethical
Respectful
Please click to close Alumni
Lower Level Music Students
Focus Group Questions
Aurals Skills II Class
(Lower Level Music Students)
January 20, 2011
- What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Life skills
- Career skills
- Analytical thinking
- Development of thinking process
- Maturity/professionalism
- Multicultural awareness (preparation for multicultural involvement)
- Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- More personal
- More one to one instruction
- Intimate
- Higher sense of accountability
- Friendly
- Faculty accessibility
- If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- On the job training
- More in field experience opportunities
- When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Friendly alumni
- Camaraderie
- Supportive
- Successful
Please click to close Lower Division Music Students
University College Day Committee
Focus Group Questions
University College Day Committee
January 13, 2011
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
Critical thinking
Intellectual independence
Learning beyond university years
Communication—effective
Written and oral
Coherent and appropriate
Develop independent thinking
Intellectual curiosity
Cultural awareness/involvement in global environment
Analytic skills
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
Small classes allow lots of options
Oral presentations
Written work
Student support functions—
ASC, advising, honors
Good librarians
Research skills
Media center
Atmosphere
Students accountable in small classes
Individualized attention
Personalized attenetion
Classes taught by professors
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Need to know how to read
Information retrieval/processing/extract what is useful
Work in teams
Leadership
Improve independent thinking
Prepare students for graduate school
Cultivate sense of professionalism
Disciplinary specific
Life-long learning
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Mixed bag—very good to barely passing/swimmers and treaders
Determined
Resilient
Juggle lives
Find balance
Overcome real obstacles
Diverse—representative of population
Hard working
Please click to close University College Day
Faculty Council
Focus Group Questions
Faculty Council
January 11, 2011
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
How to think
Communication—verbal/written
Time management
How to solve new problems
Factual synthesis and analysis
Learning is an ongoing process—life-long learning
Skills that make them employable
Capable of getting a job
Need career goals
Educated, not trained
Ability to find answers independently
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
Individual guidance
Students need more guidance
First-generation undergraduate and professional school
Faculty and staff prepared to offer help when needed
“can do” attitude of faculty
Inspire students to achieve historical (for them) expectations
Law school—stress collaboration over competition
Required pro bono work
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning—for work or graduate school, what would it be?
Convince them: “Math is your friend”
Belief in individual achievement, belier in self
Communication—written and oral
Gather and synthesize information
Use coherently
Not find “quick-fix”
Technological fluency and literacy
Sense of self-confidence to go out in the world—trust yourself
Be comfortable that issues are not black and white
Process learning
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Determined
Over-burdened
Human beings—persons
Are names/individuals
In the community
Don’t have sense of entitlement
Work very hard—recognize that they need to work hard
Have to make their own way in the world
Not usually the traditional way
Rise from adversity
Opportunity to succeed.
Please click to close Faculty Council
Graduate Counseling Students
Graduate counseling students
January 19, 2011
Edita Ruzgyte, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Clinical skills
- Knowledge that helps attain licensure
- Practical experience
- Sense of ownership about the profession
- Students need to care for the profession
- Critical thinking
- Lifelong learning experience
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Personal investment in the students by the faculty
- Good student/faculty ratio
- Professors are available to the students and respond in a very effective and timely manner
- All faculty maintains their practices
- Diversity of student body
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- Building practice – post graduation logistics
- Transition from school to practice
- Cooperation with community
- Seminars
- Better facilities
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Professional
- Competent
- Skillful
- Ethical
- Well rounded
- Well regarded in community
Please click to close Graduate Counseling Students
Graduate Counseling Faculty
Graduate Counseling faculty
January 20, 2011
Edita Ruzgyte, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Never stop being a student, continuous education
- Networking
- Peer relationships
- Broad world view
- Ethics
- Study abroad trips
- Interpersonal relationships
- Being able to apply the knowledge to the professional field
- Growth – personally and professionally
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Size
- Student to faculty ratio
- Central location of the university, we just need to promote it more effectively
- Professors have practical experience
- More study abroad trips
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- Increase size of counseling center
- More office and classroom space
- Business side of building private practice
- Overall more practical, hands on experiential learning
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Competency
- High contribution to society
- Very approachable
- “it feels like family”
Please click to close Graduate Counseling Faculty
Law Faculty Group 1
Law Faculty Focus Group
January 19, 2011
Michelle Rigual, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college:
- Problem solving and analytical skills rather than rote memorization - applying info to determine the right steps.
- Critical thinking
- Professionalism
- Communication, both written and oral
- To prioritize, analyze, and meet deadlines
- Work ethic, responsibility, and professionalism
- Logical thinking and make logical comparisons
- Collaborate with others to avoid tunnel vision.
- To debate rather than argue.
- Ask questions and investigate when necessary.
- Ethics.
Is there anything unique about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Small class size, personal, 1 to 1 interaction, contact with professors, availability and access to professors.
- More hands-on experience due to small class size.
- Perhaps more camraderie or collegiality due to small size.
- Commuter campus
- Many students are the first in their family to go to college/law school so may not come with skill set of others but also may have more motivation.
- Night school makes education available to more students.
- Has a good mix of age groups.
- 1L blogs act as group therapy, readers can relate to the experiences of fellow students.
If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning--for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- There is a need for mentoring because many students (esp. first in family as identified in #2) may not have received any from family/previous schooling.
- Externships in field of study, real life experiences
- Professional ethics courses and how to behave in a professional setting, how to dress, professional propriety and etiquette, careful use of social networking and mindfulness of how you present yourself on it, effect of having piercings & tattoos, how to send a professional email, that there is a line between personal and professional.
- Classes where solve problems and receive feedback on your solutions.
- Project management training and communication.
- Learn responsibility rather than giving excuses.
- Real world skills & basic financial skills
When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
Generally:
- “Second-rate school”
- It is a “teacher college” and well thought of in that field.
- Most are not familiar with it, if they are familiar then the perception is positive.
- Very local, best known in Fort Worth and less so the farther you get from it.
Law School:
- they have more skills than many law school grads, esp. in their areas of specialization
- capable & prepared because they have skills rather than just theory
- more practiced in legal writing
- highly pro-bono, community & service-oriented
Please click to close Law Faculty Group 1
Law Faculty Group 2
Law Faculty Focus Group
January 19, 2011
Prof. Patty Gearhart-Turner, facilitator
What is the most important thing a student should learn in college:
- critical thinking, being able to synthesize information and analyze it. Be objective and provide objective analysis.
- Communication skills, oral and written. Basic writing, grammar, and mechanical tools.
Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- In consideration of our unique student body, enhancing communication skills is essential.
If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students--enhance student learning--for work or graduate school, what would it be?
When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Local, regional students who don’t want a big law firm experience.
- Community focused
- Relational atmosphere is attractive
- Law school graduates seem confident (some of them may also be cocky!).
Please click to close Law Faculty Group 2
Law Faculty Group 3
Law school – faculty
January 18, 2011
Edita Ruzgyte, facilitator
1. What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Critical thinking
- Communication – all levels (professional, peer relationship)
- Writing and professional speech
- Conductive themselves in the work place
- Analytical skills
- Life skills
- Common sense
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Student body more diverse
- Usually first generation university graduates
- University is very student centered
- High passion for learning
- Most students are paying their way
- Students are very committed
- Evening school
- Older students
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- IT services – both support and technology
- More effective ways to asses outcomes and students’ progress
- Test reliability
- More communication and connection with historic campus
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- Preparedness
- They tend to stay locally in the community
- I wish they promoted university more actively
- Wesleyan lacks traditions that will help alumni be more active and supportive
Please click to close Law Faculty Group 3
Law Faculty Group 4
Law school – Faculty
January 18, 2011
Beth Battles, facilitator
- What is the most important thing a student should learn in college?
- Learn to learn
- How to read
- Become functioning member of society, good citizens
- Professionalism
- Ethical level
- Tolerance
- Understand diversity
- Civility
- Respect opinions
- Critical thinking
- No institution can teach all you need to know
- How to communicate that thinking
2. Is there anything special about Texas Wesleyan that makes the goal of learning different here than at any other university?
- Small classes (not so much at law school)
- Personal attention
- Apologetic feature of students
- Accessible faculty
- Caring faculty
- Less qualified students
- Diverse students (age, gender, race, etc.)
- Kind of students not too different from other law schools—but perception of “quality” of students
3. If you could choose one thing that would better prepare our students – enhance student learning – for work or graduate school, what would it be?
- Professionalism training
- Interviewing
- General respect
- Civility
- Appropriate use of email (tone, etc.)
- Appropriateness of expression
- Relearn “people skills”
- True communication
- Experiential learning
- Internal (simulated)
- External internships
- Better technology
- Practical
- Using technology
- Certified programs in technology
4. When you think about graduates of Texas Wesleyan University, what comes to mind?
- School has “deep” reputation among graduates
- Collegiality/ community of students and faculty
- Connectedness—Law grads hire students
- Supportive alumni
- Capable
- Growing presence in community
Please click to close Law Faculty Group 4
QEP Focus Group - Phase 2
Faculty Assembly Group 1
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Faculty Assembly
January 27, 2011
The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
Discussion focused on freshmen and transfer students. When asked about other groups, participants responded:
- If we focus on “all undergraduates” we are not focusing on anything
- “First generation” is not a distinct group by itself. A lot of freshmen will be first generation, there is no need to focus specifically on this group
Discussion supporting transfer students as a target group for QEP (and/or reasons why they should be picked over freshmen group)
- Freshmen already get too much attention and funding. Learning communities are designated to them
- Transfer students use less financial support, they stay longer in school and eventually pay more
- With this economical situation, people need to have a 4 year degree in order to survive competitive market, so there is a possibility that the number of transfer students from community colleges will increase.
- Retention of freshmen students is much lower (they think so) compared to transfer students
Discussion supporting freshmen as a target group for QEP:
- Marginal benefits are greater with freshmen
- In the future there may be a move to a two year colleges, that would support the idea of having freshmen as a target group.
- The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
++++++++ |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
+++++++++++ |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
++++++++++++ |
Career Preparation (tie) |
++++ |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
|
Technology (tie) |
++++ |
Experiential Learning |
+++ |
Leadership |
|
Quantitative Skills |
++++ |
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
|
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
+ |
Student Life Support (tie) |
|
Ethics (tie) |
++++ |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
++ |
Professionalism |
|
Study Abroad |
++ |
Technological Fluency |
|
Informational Literacy |
+ |
Please click to close University Faculty Group 1
Faculty Assembly Group 2
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Faculty Assembly
January 27, 2011
The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
Discussion focused on freshmen and transfer students. When asked about other groups, participants responded:
- If we focus on “all undergraduates” we are not focusing on anything
- “First generation” is not a distinct group by itself. A lot of freshmen will be first generation, there is no need to focus specifically on this group
- Discussion supporting transfer students as a target group for QEP (and/or reasons why they should be picked over freshmen group)
- Freshmen already get too much attention and funding. Learning communities are designated to them
- Transfer students use less financial support, they stay longer in school and eventually pay more
- With this economical situation, people need to have a 4 year degree in order to survive competitive market, so there is a possibility that the number of transfer students from community colleges will increase.
- Retention of freshmen students is much lower (they think so) compared to transfer students
- Discussion supporting freshmen as a target group for QEP:
- Marginal benefits are greater with freshmen
- In the future there may be a move to a two year colleges, that would support the idea of having freshmen as a target group.
- The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
++++++++ |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
+++++++++++ |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
++++++++++++ |
Career Preparation (tie) |
++++ |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
|
Technology (tie) |
++++ |
Experiential Learning |
+++ |
Leadership |
|
Quantitative Skills |
++++ |
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
|
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
+ |
Student Life Support (tie) |
|
Ethics (tie) |
++++ |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
++ |
Professionalism |
|
Study Abroad |
++ |
Technological Fluency |
|
Informational Literacy |
+ |
Please click to close University Faculty Group 2
Faculty Assembly Group 3
Faculty Focus Group 3
January 27, 2011
Comments Regarding “target groups”:
Incoming freshmen
“gateway” Freshmen Sophomore students
Lower Division students
Already a lot of initiatives toward them
All undergraduate students
“gateway” Freshmen Sophomore students
Lower Division students
Too broad
First-generation students
We have no data – how many are there?
If we are going to use this, we need to identify how many we have
At-risk students
Means what?
Already doing a lot; need to define what “at risk” is (academic, family issues, etc.)
Transfer students
Non-Traditional (as an additional target group)
Other Comments:
Suggestions:
Focus on our largest group
Nontraditional
Maybe a group of lower division (Fresh/Soph)
Regarding the broad themes topic discussion, the following was written:
Communication (written/oral) – “a diploma without this skill is garbage”
Written BELOW the themes listed at the bottom of the page:
*Diversity Issues* (I suppose this person was interested in adding something regarding diversity in regard to a possible broad theme we should explore)
Please click to close University Faculty Group 3
Faculty Assembly Group 4
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Faculty Assembly 1/27/2011
1. The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
- Incoming freshmen
- All undergraduate students
- First-generation students
- At-risk students
- Transfer students
Discussion:
- Discussions were mostly on freshmen and transfer students. Some of the concerns on other groups were as follow:
- Transfer students were much weaker in the past. They are on signature experience.
- Higher retention rates were obtained for transfer students.
- There could be an overlap between at-risk and first-generation students.
- First generation students may not be classified as a distinct group since there could be an overlap between first-generation and freshmen.
- Incoming freshmen and at-risk students are already receiving lot of resources.
- Inquiries about commuter students.
Conclusion:
There was a consensus on focusing more on incoming freshmen group and all undergraduate students, because these two groups would cover the majority of the student body.
2. The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
The results are parallel to overall survey results. The following table summarizes themes that were chosen by participants:
Topics |
Votes
(out of 10 total) |
Communication (written/oral) |
7 |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
9 |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
8 |
Career Preparation (tie) |
2 |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
1 |
Technology (tie) |
1 |
Experiential Learning |
2 |
Leadership |
|
Quantitative Skills |
1 |
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
1 |
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
1 |
Student Life Support (tie) |
2 |
Ethics (tie) |
2 |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
4 |
Professionalism |
3 |
Study Abroad |
|
Technological Fluency |
2 |
Informational Literacy |
4 |
Please click to close University Faculty Group 4
Students Group 1
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Student group
February 14, 2011
The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
Discussion focused on freshmen and transfer students and was very similar to the one by faculty members during focus group in faculty assembly.
The main ideas was that transfer students to not receive the same amount of services, or/and it is difficult for them to fit in some specific university functions. Some of the students said that it is very difficult for them to adapt to this university as their special circumstances, as transfer students, are not taken in consideration. They also have less time to complete all extra requirements.
Students also expressed their ideas that transfer students are usually more serious and have higher retention numbers.
The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
++++++ |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
++++++ |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
+++ |
Career Preparation (tie) |
+++++++ |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
+++++++ |
Technology (tie) |
+ |
Experiential Learning |
+ |
Leadership |
+ |
Quantitative Skills |
+ |
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
++++ |
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
|
Student Life Support (tie) |
|
Ethics (tie) |
|
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
|
Professionalism |
|
Study Abroad |
+ |
Technological Fluency |
|
Informational Literacy |
|
Please click to close Undergraduate Students Group 1
Students Group 2
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Student group
February 14, 2011
- The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
The discussion began generally, that all the groups have various needs, but the group all undergraduates captures them all. They felt that at-risk and 1st generation needed the most help in adjusting to college life. The discussion was broad and thoughtful about what services the university could offer these students, such as mentoring. They said the environment of the university (small classes, tight-knit community, family-like departments) is more important than the content of the courses.
- The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
xxxx |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
xxx |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
xxxx |
Career Preparation (tie) |
xxx |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
xx |
Technology (tie) |
|
Experiential Learning |
xx |
Leadership |
xxxx |
Quantitative Skills |
x |
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
x |
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
|
Student Life Support (tie) |
xx |
Ethics (tie) |
xx |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
x |
Professionalism |
x |
Study Abroad |
|
Technological Fluency |
|
Informational Literacy |
|
The students first chose the themes and then began the discussion. They felt critical thinking is not stresses in high school even though they talk about it. Learning is more than memorization.
One student mentioned dual undergraduate/masters programs and then discussed the importance of internships, which then dominated the discussion. Students need experience in the field—they take classes and get a degree but often don’t think of why they are taking them.
Students need more help managing themselves—perhaps this fits in the Professionalism category or Student Life.
Career preparation: Opportunity to see what it’s like to do certain job, but others saw it as less important, although many students don’t know details of anything except service jobs like WalMart or McDonalds. Must get some experience so they are not surprised by the realities of the job. Specifically, one student said that Mass Comm majors don’t have the resources available to learn about their field. Students said they can’t believe that internships are not required. Many students seek degree only, but not experience.
There needs to be a limit to hand-holding. Experiential learning helps students to have success and provided motivation. Traditional classroom is the same thing they have been doing since childhood. Emphasis on the connection between experiential learning and motivation.
Study abroad is important.
There was some discussion on safety and security as important for learning.
Other things that improve learning: passionate teachers, use of technology, applied to life.
Professionalism and Ethics should also be emphasized: dress, speak, email, write, hold conversations like a professional.
Please click to close Undergraduate Students Group 2
University Staff Group 1
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Staff
February 16, 2011
The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
The discussion began with the fact that International students were not on the list. The globalization of the world means more than a student getting international experience, but also the university including international students.
First-generation students were also deemed important to focus on. They don’t know how college works. This classification goes across all others on the list.
Focusing on incoming freshman is useful if we are thinking about systemic change because we can measure results in five years from a more consistent and stable group. They also fit in other categories.
In the discussion of all undergraduates, some said that focus would then affect all other groups, while others thought the category too broad to be useful.
Group agreed that we already have programs for incoming and at-risk students.
“Target group” not on the list is the in-between or “almost” or “not-quite” students (not honors but not at-risk).
There is also a danger in breaking down students into even more categories than we have currently.
Ultimately, the group suggested, the topic for the QEP would determine the target groups. Depending on the plan, it could make other programs and initiatives obsolete.
The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
xxxx |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
xxxx |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
xxxxx |
Career Preparation (tie) |
x |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
|
Technology (tie) |
x |
Experiential Learning |
xxx |
Leadership |
x |
Quantitative Skills |
|
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
|
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
|
Student Life Support (tie) |
|
Ethics (tie) |
xx |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
|
Professionalism |
x |
Study Abroad |
|
Technological Fluency |
x |
Informational Literacy |
xx |
Communication was deemed very important. Students must be able to articulate/speak effectively and professionally (using the jargon of the field). Even in the classroom they need to articulate what they need to know. This is true at undergraduate and graduate level.
Professionalism—knowing how to communicate
Critical thinking and writing includes Communications—and analytical thinking and problem solving (all are related).
Analytical thinking/problem solving is critical (and not just in terms of a classroom topic)—need to understand consequences of actions. Lack of consequential learning affects ethics. This includes the “soft skills” of career preparation.
Not on the list but crucial: globalization/cultural awareness/multinational economics.
We are a nation of entrepreneurs—problems are being solved all over today.
We miss out on teaching opportunities for cultural awareness/globalization in Texas.
Study Abroad is important because it provides concrete evidence of things they learn on the internet. Need access and resources to do it. They understand that a global mindset exists, but don’t really see it, or know it to act on it. Can get cultural/global awareness through the Humanities program.
There was then a very spirited discussion about the division between the paternalistic idea of what students need from learning and what they think they want. As a university, we must think in terms of not preparing students to get a specific job, but wonder what kind of jobs will there be? We need to prepare them for what jobs are out there, not the job they want. Students need to be prepared for the jobs that will be, not just jobs that exist today. Students can be prepared for or create the job they want as well as the jobs in traditional careers.
We need to prepare graduates to be learning all their lives because they will most likely change careers: Critical thinking, communication, analytical thinking. These are skills that enable students to know who to learn (not just like to learn)
Informational literacy is tied to analytical thinking—knowing how to discern information, to find and use credible sources.
Leadership also important—tied to ethics and social skills.
Please click to close University Staff Group 1
University Staff Group 2
QEP Topic Selection
Staff Focus Group
February 16, 2011
1. The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
- Incoming freshmen
- All undergraduate students
- First-generation students
- At-risk students
- Transfer students
Discussion:
- Discussions were mostly on at-risk students. How are at-risk students defined? Is that based on low GPA, some kind of academic success, or are there other factors such as emotional, social, physical. Are these socio-economically disadvantaged students? Many of them would not consider themselves as at-risk student. It may be important to distinguish at-risk for retention purposes and academic purposes. Ultimate goal should be keeping graduation retention.
- The general idea on incoming freshmen is that there are lots of other things going on with them, so it is not necessary to put additional effort for that group. They are already receiving lot of resources.
- All undergrad students may include other groups but there is risk that this group will be too general.
- Inquiries about commuter students, athletes, single moms, English language learners.
Conclusion:
There was a consensus on focusing more on at-risk student group. Depending on how at-risk students are defined, all other groups that QEP must address could be a sub-category of at-risk students.
2. The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
This was a group formed of 6 participants and they unanimously selected
- Communication
- Critical Thinking
- Analytical Thinking / Problem Solving
- Technology
- Student Life Support
Some ideas:
- Communication may be a barrier to at-risk students
- At-risk students may not be fluent with technology
- Student life support should be holistic. It should include everything outside of classrooms
- Financial aid
- Counseling center
- Organizations
- Resources
- Advising
- Child care services
- Transportation
- Most of the other topics come along with these 5 topics selected.
Please click to close University Staff Group 2
Student Government Association 1
QEP Topic Selection
Second round focus group
Student Government Association
February 17, 2011
The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
Incoming freshmen
All undergraduate students
First-generation students
At-risk students
Transfer students
Discussion summary:
The discussion seemed to be more about ways to get students involved on campus—which, they acknowledged should improve student learning if students are engaged.
Agreed that we already target incoming students, and should focus instead on the “in-between students.”
They did say that incoming students are lacking the skill set of learning how to learn.
- The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
|
These themes were selected that many times |
|
|
Communication (written/oral) |
xxxxxx |
Critical Thinking and Writing |
xxxx |
Analytical Thinking/Problem solving (tie) |
xxxxx |
Career Preparation (tie) |
xxxxx |
Graduate School Preparation (tie) |
xxx |
Technology (tie) |
xxx |
Experiential Learning |
xxx |
Leadership |
x |
Quantitative Skills |
|
Research (undergraduate/graduate) |
xx |
Community Awareness/Citizenship |
x |
Student Life Support (tie) |
xx |
Ethics (tie) |
xxx |
Collaborative Learning (tie) |
|
Cross-disciplinary learning |
xx |
Professionalism |
|
Study Abroad |
|
Technological Fluency |
|
Informational Literacy |
|
Career preparation should happen earlier in college.
Experiential learning gives a hands-on feel. The best way to learn is by doing.
Many students agreed that 4 of the top five on the list are “survival skills” : Communication, Critical Thinking and Writing, Analytical Thinking/Problem Solving, Career Preparation. Undergraduate degrees aren’t what they used to be, so students need to be prepared to take the next step and then the next. These skills help in the transition from college life to real life.
These also are tied to leadership and ethics. Ethics should be ranked higher. Ethics and Leadership are essential in being a complete human being. Can’t keep a job if you are not ethical. Also should stress leadership besides student life.
If you have leadership and ethics as well as : Communication, Critical Thinking and Writing, Analytical Thinking/Problem Solving, Career Preparation.—this and cross disciplinary learning-- you are prepared for a career—you will have learned how to adapt to changing circumstances.
More on cross-disciplinary learning: jobs don’t usually require only what you have learned in college, you must be able to keep learning.
Technology and thinking outside the box are important.
Community Awareness/citizenship—must know that is going on in the world and community.
Student life support makes students involved and increases retention
Please click to close Student Government Association
Student Government Association 2
QEP Topic Selection
SGA Focus Group
February 17, 2011
1. The results of the QEP Topic Selection survey that you were asked to complete show that these “target groups” of students are the top five most appropriate to be the focus of a Quality Enhancement Plan at Texas Wesleyan:
- Incoming freshmen
- All undergraduate students
- First-generation students
- At-risk students
- Transfer students
Discussion:
- Discussions were mostly on incoming freshmen. More emphasis should be given to increase the retention rates.
- Even when I mentioned that there are they are already receiving lot of resources, the general idea on incoming freshmen didn’t change.
- All undergrad students would be too general. If QEP needs to be more specific, then it should be more on incoming freshmen.
- There were some discussions on commuter students, graduate students, non-traditional students.
Conclusion:
The consensus was on incoming freshmen.
2. The same survey showed that these broad themes are likely to improve student learning at Wesleyan. On the second list are additional themes that emerged from the 16 focus groups we have conducted.
Please take a few moments to circle the five that most stand out to you. If there is a topic that you think should be on the list but is not, please indicate that.
The themes that were selected were:
- Communication (9)
- Critical Thinking (6)
- Analytical Thinking / Problem Solving (8)
- Career Preparation (4)
- Graduate School Preparation (2)
- Technology (4)
- Experiential Learning (Internship) (2)
- Leadership (2)
- Student life Support (2)
- Professionalism (3)
Some ideas:
- Internships should be more important
- Academic Support Center is needed
- Sports (NCAA instead of NAIA)
Please click to close Student Government Association 2